Draft Defamation Bill : House of Lords Paper 203 Session 2010-12

Draft Defamation Bill : House of Lords Paper 203 Session 2010-12


The Joint Committee on the Draft Defamation Bill welcomes many of the reforms proposed in the draft Bill. However, the report proposes many detailed amendments to the defences available against libel claims, mainly designed to strike a fairer balance between the protection of reputation and freedom of speech. For example, greater protection is proposed for scientists and academics writing in peer-reviewed articles. The Government's proposals do not do enough to address the key problems in defamation law - the unacceptably high costs which make access to justice difficult for many. The Committee proposes a series of reforms aimed at ensuring that disputes are generally resolved rapidly by mediation or arbitration, rather than via the courts. An essential step in encouraging early resolution of disputes is the abolition of jury trials in defamation actions, in all but exceptional cases. Judges will then be required to take key decisions affecting the outcome of the case at an early stage, before massive legal costs are incurred. Trivial cases should be weeded out at an early stage. A new notice and take-down procedure for the internet is proposed.Internet hosts gain the protection of the law provided they act responsibly by following the new procedure. Any anonymous postings must be taken down upon complaint, unless authors are prepared to identify themselves or there is an overriding public interest in publication. Furthermore, is should be made more difficult for companies to use their financial muscle and the threat of court action to silence critics.

Similar Books

ISBN 10: 0198744498
ISBN 13: 9780198744498

24 Dec 2019
Thomas Keymer

ISBN 10: 0062659650
ISBN 13: 9780062659651

12 Jan 2017
Deborah E. Lipstadt

ISBN 10: 1510757538
ISBN 13: 9781510757530

19 Nov 2019
Alan Dershowitz

ISBN 10: 1904887465
ISBN 13: 9781904887461

25 Apr 2011
Andrea Martin

ISBN 10: 0300221541
ISBN 13: 9780300221541

02 May 2017
Don Herzog

ISBN 10: 000715805X
ISBN 13: 9780007158058

01 Nov 2004
Merlin Holland

ISBN 10: 1509916709
ISBN 13: 9781509916702

22 Aug 2019
Professor David Rolph

ISBN 10: 0230244610
ISBN 13: 9780230244610

10 Oct 2014
Timothy Dwyer

ISBN 10: 0691162506
ISBN 13: 9780691162508

10 Mar 2014
Cass R. Sunstein

ISBN 10: 0252081730
ISBN 13: 9780252081736

06 May 2016
Sarah K. Fields

ISBN 10: 0198719779
ISBN 13: 9780198719779

07 Sep 2016
Jaani Riordan

ISBN 10: 1509920811
ISBN 13: 9781509920815

26 Jul 2018
Dr Randall Stephenson